The Power Behind the Throne: Who Really Ran Memphis?
By Joe Lowry
Before 1910, when Edward H. Crump became mayor of Memphis, the city’s business had been managed by 17 mayors in 14 years.
While the mayors were responsible for running the local government, an informal group of influential Memphians – lawyers, judges, political influencers and businessmen – met secretly and made decisions for the mayor to implement.
This private network could make or break the mayor without ever casting a vote.
As the Commercial Appeal noted in its Oct. 22, 1907 edition, “Wouldn’t it be interesting to know who was in the Inner Circle?”
They were the city’s elite – conservatives with old money who had deep ties to the courts and legal system – and who were not necessarily on the side of progress and modernization.[1] Every mayor prior to Crump operated under this system.
The mayors and their terms:
- John Park, 1865-1866
- William Lofland, 1866-1868
- Edgar M. McDevitt, 1868
- John W. Leftwich, 1868-1869
- John T. Swayne, 1869
- John W. Leftwich, 1869-1870
- John Johnson, 1870-1874
- John Loague, 1874-1876
- John T. Flippin, 1876-1879 [2]
- T. Porter, 1879-1881
- John Overton, 1881-1883
- David P. Hadden,[3] 1883-1891
- D. Bethell, 1891-1893
- L. Clapp, 1893-1895
- Walker L. Clapp, 1895-1898
- John Joseph Williams, 1898-1906
- James H. Malone, 1906-1910 [4]
_____________________________________________________________________
Crump succeeded Malone and served three two-year terms as mayor from 1910 through 1915. When he came into office, he put the kibosh on the group’s activities.
The Crump machine operated behind the scenes and later effectively chose the mayors who succeeded him.
After Crump, mayors and their terms were:
- George C. Love, 1915-1916, a Crump choice
- Thomas Ashcraft, 1916 -1917
Ashcraft was not a political lieutenant, a part of the machine’s inner circle, or a Crump family intimate. His relationship with Crump was functional, respectful, and rooted in the administrative structure of Memphis government rather than personal loyalty. He was a reliable, competent administrator who worked smoothly within the machine’s expectations. He maintained a decent working relationship with Crump.
- Harry Litty, 1917-1918
Born in 1862 in Toledo, Ohio, Litty came to Memphis in 1886 for railroad engineering and construction work. He later studied law under Col. G.A.C. Holt and was admitted to bar 1890. He was appointed Internal Revenue Service collector under the Grover Cleveland administration. He was a member of the city’s Board of Public Works (1896–1900) and president of the City Club of Memphis (founded in 1908).
Litty was not aligned with Crump. He was genuinely independent. He was a blue‑collar, real‑people mayor, respected by working Memphians, not owned by old money or political machines. He was practical and infrastructure minded, thanks to his roots in engineering and public works. He was one of the rare mayors who held actual executive authority without machine backing — non‑Crump, non‑elite, non‑patronage.
Litty also drove the first official train across the Great Bridge (Frisco Bridge) on May 12, 1892 — a major Memphis civic event.
- George C. Love served as a commissioner during this period and held the office of mayor in 1915–1916.
City commissioners included Leo Goodman, Charles B. Quinn, E.B. LeMaster, W.T. “Fatty” McLain and Frank L. Monteverde. The last two voted with Litty for the two-platoon system 1918, bringing on two shifts of firefighters.
Monteverde served as the Commissioner of Fire and Police. He succeeded Litty as Mayor in 1918.
Where and who was the inner circle during this period?
The private network included the influential people in Memphis: former Confederate officers, businessmen, lawyers, judges and others who were politically connected. They met secretly in private and quietly shared decisions, guiding the mayors’ decisions and resisting modernization.
This was the kind of group that could make or break the mayor. This group kept the non-revenue-producing government entities, such as the police and fire departments, understaffed and under equipped.
Group members tended to be conservatives from old money, anti-reform and deeply tied to the courts and legal system. In short, they were the Memphis elite. Included in the group were:
- Luke Wright, a prominent political figure, diplomat, and attorney from Memphis, often remembered as the “Hero of 1878” for his leadership during the city’s devastating yellow fever epidemic. Wright was a highly respected lawyer and central figure in American government at the turn of the 20th century. After serving in the Confederate army, he practiced law in Memphis and was appointed by the governor as Tennessee Attorney General (Shelby County) from 1870 to 1878. He served as the Secretary of War under President Theodore Roosevelt (1908–1909), the only Confederate veteran to hold that post. Wright also was the first S. Ambassador to Japan (1906–1907) and the Governor General of the Philippines (1904–1906). He is buried in Forest Hill Cemetery.
- Napolean Hill[5] was a prominent businessman and investor, often referred to as the Merchant Prince of Memphis. He was one of the wealthiest men in the city during the Gilded Age, amassing a fortune that began with a $10,000 stake earned during the California Gold Rush. He is buried at Elmwood Cemetery.
- Hugh Lawson White Brinkley, popularly known as Hu Brinkley, was a prominent businessman, philanthropist and civic leaderwho played a pivotal role in the city’s growth in the late 19th century. He is buried at Elmwood Cemetery.
- Samuel Tate Carneswas a prominent businessman and visionary known as Memphis’s great innovator for introducing the city to modern infrastructure, including its first electric lights, telephones, and automobiles.
- Henry Luehrmann Brewery & Saloon: Before opening his famous hotel, Luehrmann was a successful brewer. He built much of his initial fortune through the sale of Schlitz Beer and owned a popular saloon in the city.
In 1887, he unveiled his magnificent Luehrmann Hotel on Main Street (the site of the Commerce Title Building today). It was renowned for its high-end dining room, which featured exotic fare like South American partridge and live lobsters kept in basement tanks.
Luehrmann was widely regarded as one of the most honest and trusted businessmen in Memphis during his time.
- Dominic Canale (1843–1919) was a prominent Italian American entrepreneur who founded Canale & Co.in 1866. Originally a produce wholesaler, his company grew to become the largest distributor of its kind in the Southern United States and eventually the primary beer distributor for the Mid-South region.
- Judge Eli Shelby Hammond (1838–1904) was the first judge of the United States District Court for the Western District of Tennessee after it was authorized as a separate judgeship in 1878. Based in Memphis, he served on the federal bench for 26 years until his death in 1904. Judicial Appointment: Hammond had been nominated by President Rutherford B. Hayes on June 15, 1878, was confirmed by the Senate, and received his commission just two days later.
- Job Hammond (J.H.) Goodlett (1800–1885) was a prominent pioneer and early settler who played a significant role in the initial development of Memphis and Shelby County. He was a landowner and cotton merchant.
- Robert Dudley Frayser (1840–1893) was a prominent Memphis attorney, financier, and businessman in the late 19th century. He was the son of Dr. John Randolph Frayser, a pioneer physician. The Frayser community in north Memphis is believed to have been named after him.
- Robert Reed Church Sr. (1839–1912) was recognized as the South’s first Black millionaire; he built his fortune in real estate. Church strategically bought devalued property during the 1878 yellow fever epidemic and went on to own saloons, a hotel, and the Solvent Savings Bank, the city’s first Black-owned bank. At his death, his estate was worth roughly $1 million.
- John Snowden was a major landowner and real estate developer. Snowden and his sons were responsible for creating some of the city’s first affluent subdivisions, including Annesdale Park in 1903 and Snowden Homestead in 1910.
- Elias Lowenstein and his brothers owned a dry goods business. Elias built a house on the edge of the fashionable Adams Avenue district. They also opened what would become one of the city’s leading department stores, Lowenstein’s.
- John W. Dillard was Memphis cotton man who founded T.B. Dillard Cotton Factors. He was one of the original incorporators of the Memphis Cotton Exchange in 1875. He is buried in Elmwood Cemetery.
- Colton Green (1833-1900), although not a politician, was a powerful figure in the city. He had been a Confederate Cavalry Officer and after the war became an insurance and banking leader. He was the first president of the State Savings bank and one of Memphis’ leading citizens. He was a supporter of clean water and sanitation and a public library. Grocery Business, He was active in the Mystic Society of Memphis and organized the Tennessee Club in 1875. He is buried at Elmwood.
- Judge John Overton, who served as mayor from 1881-1883, continued to be active in the city’s development. He was one of three men to put his name on the Rice tract in 1794. His name was associated with the first documents, deeds, surveys, court cases, ferry rights, and most of the original property in Memphis. His family remained prominent in Memphis business, real estate and civic affairs.
Memphis, as with many American cities, has long had a behind-the-scenes group whose members had a hand in guiding those who had been elected to lead it. Years from now, perhaps there will be an update to this story featuring those whose voices that today speak loudest.
Sources
- Memphis Commercial Appeal, October 22-23, 1917, Page 6
- Memphis Commercial Appeal, January 7, 1918, Page 6
- Crisis and Commission: Government in Memphis, Tennessee, by Lynnette Boney Wrenn
- Memphis Public Library, numerous articles
- Shelby County Archives, numerous articles
[1] Between 1874 and 1909, seven fire chiefs requested additional manpower, apparatus, alarm systems and water supply additions, but none of the mayors provided it. Mayors Loague, Flippin, Clapp, Williams and Malone ignored the Fire Department’s legitimate requests. At the time, the department ran only one shift, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Because there was no kitchen at the fire houses, firefighters were allowed to go home to eat. But when the alarm was tapped out and the bell on the fire station rang, they were expected to get to the fire any way they could.
[2] Flippin was mayor during the yellow fever epidemic that resulted in 5,000 deaths.
[3] Hadden was partial to the Fire Department.
[4] Author’s Note: Every mayor held up improvements to the Police and Fire Departments. Until 1888, Memphis only had four engines, one ladder, and one chemical engine. Considering the area’s size, both in square miles and population, as well as the fire load, the city should have had six engine companies, two ladders, and two or three chemical companies. Memphis was the last city in the U.S. to purchase a water tower. A ladder truck could deliver just 250 to 300 gallons per minute at six stories. A water tower could deliver 750 gallons a minute to eight floors.
The Police Department had 1 chief and only 44 men. A city the size of Memphis should have had 85 officers.
[5] He was not the 20th-century self-help author of Think and Grow, Oliver Napoleon Hill.
