Question Answered! – Susanne Scruggs

This article is a part of our Ask Away! user submitted question series. This question was posed by listener Genie S. who asked about former Memphian Susanne Scruggs. OMH’s Vince Hughes researched Mrs. Scruggs life and legacy and we present this article as our answer.

Susanne Coulan Scruggs ( her first name has been spelled Susanne, Suzanne and Susie ) could
have easily filled her days and social calendar with teas and luncheons and the activities of her
six children and her husband, a prominent Shelby County attorney and judge.

Instead, Susanne devoted much of her adult life to improving conditions for many of the least
fortunate in her adopted city of Memphis. Born in Boston, she moved to Memphis in 1889 after
marrying attorney Thomas M. Scruggs. In the next 50 years, she would lead endeavors to
provide safe places for children to play, improve public education, create a juvenile court,
provide free medical care to needy children, and initiate family welfare programs.

A founding member of the Nineteenth Century Club, Susanne is credited with directing a
fundraising reception that ensured the opening of the Cossitt Library in 1894. After that
successful event, she began to focus her efforts on social programs to help Memphis children at a
time when progressive leaders across the country were tackling similar community issues.
Memphis had the added complications of recovering from the Yellow Fever epidemic just two decades earlier.

Many of the groups and agencies organized through Susanne’s leadership are organizations we
take for granted today. At the turn of the century, she was on the cutting edge. She was perhaps
best known for founding the Memphis Playground Association in 1908 to ensure supervised
playgrounds in Memphis parks. The organization creatively enlisted unruly boys to be part of a
“Playground Police”, transforming disorder into self-government with the young men serving as
protectors of younger children. The Playground Association became the most influential child
welfare organization in the city. Its leaders were responsible for the creation of a children’s ward
in the City Hospital and the establishment of a Juvenile Court.

In working to create the Juvenile Court, Susanne corresponded with Judge Benjamin Barr
Lindsey of Denver, a national pioneer in the juvenile justice movement. Born in West Tennessee,
Lindsey provided legal forms for the Memphis reformers to use in creating the Court and
Detention Home. Susanne disagreed with a decision to make the Juvenile Court part of the city
court system instead of the county probate courts, saying city court was an extension of the
police department. As chairman of the Juvenile Court Advisory Board, she worked to make the
best of the situation and fought for a larger budget. While the board did not receive all of its
requests, Susanne stood firm on several issues including a female probation officer.

Susanne ultimately was dissatisfied with the Juvenile Court and resigned from the Advisory
Board in protest. She founded the Children’s Protective Union, a complementary agency that
found homes for children. Susanne argued that dependent children should not experience the
Juvenile Court system because it was designed for delinquent children. In her work with the
Union, she served as a “friendly visitor” to homes of children served by the agency.

In the first decade of 1900, Susanne organized two public school associations: the Woman’s
Public Schools Association in 1905 and the Public Education Association in 1907. The Woman’s
Public Schools Association focused on efficiency in education. They fought for free paper and
books for needy children and less classroom crowding. In one letter to the Memphis School
Board, Susanne made an argument still debated today. She contended that promotion to the next
grade should be based on a child’s daily work instead of a single exam.

The second educational group, the Public Education Association, had a broader agenda in the
schools. Through that group, Susanne led advocacy efforts for greater financial stability for the
school system, improved sanitation in schools, medical exams for students and the serving of hot
lunches. Both of the education associations focused on increasing parental involvement. Susanne
was active in both state and city levels of the Congress of Mothers and Parent Teacher
Associations and she urged women to participate as a way to make their voices heard until they
earned the right to vote.

It should be noted that while Susanne worked for child-welfare reform during a time of
segregation, she often supported Julia Hooks and other African-American reformers in their
parallel efforts.Susanne looked beyond specific issues to address the broader social context. In
1913, at the statewide meeting of the Congress of Mothers and Parent Teacher Associations, she
made a motion asking the organization president to name a committee to draft a series of bills to
be introduced in the General Assembly. Among the 11 proposals were:

● A provision that the state enforce child support by fathers, with incarceration as the
penalty;
● A requirement that girls under 16 not be required to testify in open court in cases of rape;
● That women be allowed to serve as juvenile court judges and on school boards; and
● That “all laws and measures affecting the welfare of children shall be state-wide in
scope.”

Susanne’s vision was years ahead of the General Assembly, but many of her proposals
became law during her lifetime. In the book Gateway to Justice , scholar Jennifer Trost
described Susanne as the most prominent child welfare activist in Memphis in the early
Progressive years.

Susanne Scruggs was born 25 Aug 1864 in Boston and died on 29 Jan 1945 in Memphis. She is
buried in Elmwood Cemetery. She was the daughter of James and Mary Conlan.

She and her husband, Thomas Murphy Scruggs, lived at 135 N. Montgomery, Memphis. They
had six children, all of which are now deceased. The last child died in 1995.
Thomas was a civil Engineer.

There is a collection of Mrs. Scruggs’ papers in the Memphis Room, Memphis Public Library.

The index for this collection is available on-line here and  here for download.